The Winter of Our Discontent – Review

I’m making my way through my Steinbeck’s and this year started with the read of The Winter of Our Discontent. I went into reading this book without much of an idea regarding what the book was about. I picked up this vintage like edition several years ago at a secondhand store simply because it was Steinbeck and I liked the cover.

“When a condition or a problem becomes too great, humans have the protection of not thinking about it.  But it goes inward and minces up with a lot of other things already there and what comes out is discontent and uneasiness, guilt and a compulsion to get something – anything – – before it is all gone.”

The life of Ethan Hawley is routine and unexciting. After his father suffered a financial crisis, Ethan and his family have seemingly lost their “station” and prestige as a family of “old money” leaving Ethan to earn his living as a grocery store clerk. Ethan’s wife, Mary, and his kids are ashamed of Ethan’s lowly station in life. Although Mary and Ethan love each other, she can never seem to understand when her husband is being serious or if he’s joking. Mary struggles with the stigma attached to her husband’s means of making an honest living. His family and friends are discontent with his attitude and encourage him to take some risks; one way he could do that is to invest some money his wife inherited. Another, more popular way would be to take some shortcuts (bribes) and why not, everyone else seems to be doing it.

Ethan stands on principle in the early part of the book, he considers himself an honest man and tries to instill this in his own children who seem to be oblivious to why integrity and honesty are important. Well meaning friends offer unsolicited advise all the time and Ethan seems to consider this privately on his night time walks since he often can’t sleep.

“My dreams are the problems of the day stepped up to absurdity, a little like men dancing, wearing the horns and masks of animals.”

After repeated conversation from the people in Ethan’s life, you see a shift in Ethan’s attitude about how to quiet everyone down and get them off his back.

Ethan had good motives and I admired him for not being greedy by investing his wife’s inheritance. He shows a level of integrity and self control in contrast to the majority of the people in the book, all out to make money even if it might result in loss to others. As a victim (Ethan feels) to bad advice and dishonesty, Ethan resolve seems to ebb away. Ethan dealings with others becomes a chess game, like a battle wits. He sets out to show people that he will take their advice but on his own terms.

Steinbeck allows us to follow Ethan’s internal musings and struggles and as he plays the game, a series of events unfold changing the lives of many people in Ethan’s life. Ethan goes so far as to leverage his childhood friendship with Danny, the town drunk, another piece in his chess game. What happens to Danny caused me to think this was the point of no return in Ethan’s game.

Not much happens in the beginning plot wise, but this book feels more like a study in human morality. What guides a persons decisions? How long can a person listen to his conscience before he is corrupted by the attitudes and practices of those around him? Steinbeck’s familiar literary showmanship is evident. What does discontent lead a person to do? At what cost and is it worth it?

17 thoughts on “The Winter of Our Discontent – Review

  1. Grab the Lapels says:

    Based on the last bit of your review, I can understand why this would be a good book to teach in high school. Those morality questions are important when teens are put into situations where similar-think is encouraged to fit in.

    Like

    • booksbythecup says:

      You know what, I never read any Steinbeck in high school but I think this one would have been worth taking a look at in a classroom setting at that age. I hear that often, everyone else is doing whatever but does that make it right or OK, even if you don’t get caught? I know a lot of people I’ve talked to about Steinbeck’s more popular, The Grapes of Wrath, is one people tell me they read in school. I think because it deals with the Depression and the Dust Bowl Migration might be why

      Like

      • Grab the Lapels says:

        I didn’t read any Steinbeck in high school. I kept taking “advanced English,” which I think is code for “you’re going to graduate high school and never read a single book that any other high school student read.” I don’t get the system.

        Like

      • booksbythecup says:

        I had a rant last year about what I would have liked to see in required reading in school. I think as a young reader I didn’t always like the idea of required reading, we didn’t have a list to choose from, it was this is what you have to read and will be tested on. I remember a few, like Lord of the Flies (which mentally I remember hating and can’t seem to bring myself to read it again as an adult) and The Good Earth, which I remember disliking but when I read it as an adult, twice now, it’s actually a book I really like.

        https://booksbythecup.wordpress.com/2018/07/25/the-good-earth-review/

        Like

      • Grab the Lapels says:

        Ah, yes! I read your review of The Good Earth. I’m not sure what I would have liked to read in high school. I’m not sure a lot of it would be parent approved. I would have liked to read journalism books in history class, and maybe the history and English teachers have a tandem teaching method. I would have liked to read Native Son because it has so many questions about ethics, but the murder and decapitation would have been a no. More dystopian lit, maybe? 1984? I’m just not sure…..I didn’t read a ton when I was that age. I was obsessed with the internet, which was just getting into people’s homes.

        Like

      • booksbythecup says:

        I guess there is a lot for teachers to consider as far as what happens in the book. I know I read a Richard Wright book on my own in high school but can’t remember which one. I might need to call my mom and see if she has any remnants of my old book reports. I am sure I wrote one on one of his books and The Color Purple too. In going to think about where those could be. I would love to see what my teenage self said about those. I read 1984 a few years ago and am thinking about a reread.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s